Detective Hole: Another Brilliant Mess
Some character types never seem to leave crime fiction. One of the most persistent is the brilliant but broken detective: socially difficult, emotionally damaged, and very often drunk. Netflix’s adaptation of The Devil’s Star , released under the title Detective Hole , returns to that well-worn template with Jo Nesbø’s Harry Hole. It is a familiar setup, and by now arguably an overused one, but it still works often enough that the genre keeps coming back to it. My own first encounter with this type of character was probably Robbie Coltrane as Fitz in Cracker . That remains a hard version to beat. I happened to rewatch it a year or two ago after stumbling across it on a streaming service, and it held up remarkably well: messy, abrasive, intelligent, and more believable than many later variations. Since then, the same basic archetype has appeared again and again: the alcoholic genius, the socially misaligned investigator, the detective who can solve everyone else’s problems but not his...